A minister, a professor, and a knight walk into an airport...
posted by brian at 04:40 PM
Last Monday night we were rushing to the Dallas/Ft. Worth airport in our rental car for our flight back to Cleveland, talking about all the awesome people we met at PyCon. We returned the car to the appropriate lot, located at the south end of the five-mile-long airport, and took a shuttle to our departure gate. Our flight was boarding in five minutes.
Ian printed our boarding passes and distributed them. Luckily, there was nobody in line at the security checkpoint, and we were prepared to be sitting on the plane in no time. An older woman took our boarding passes and IDs to wave us through. After a moment, no such waving was granted. "Where's the expiration date?" she asked me, looking over my Rhode Island identification. I told her that it was just a state ID, not a driver's license (I don't drive), and there is no expiration date. I'm accustomed to saying this at every airport, and the reply I usually get is "You're absolutely right sir, go right ahead."
Not with this woman. After trying to persuade her in a friendly manner it became clear that she wasn't having any of my "questionable" identification. "This says you're under 21, which is not true, and the picture doesn't even look like you." I offered to remove my glasses, but that didn't cut it. "Do you have any other forms of 'current' identification?" Ah ha! My Case RTA pass from last semester — it has an expiration date and a more recent photo. She looked it over and apparently it was not good enough since it expired on January 17th.
This is when Ian and Chris joined in. An ID with my name and picture on it that expired one month ago is not current enough? Surely it's not much different from the same form of ID that expires, say, tomorrow? Chris argued with her over her strict definition of "current" while I pulled every card I had out of my wallet. "How about a credit card?" I offered. "It has my name and an expiration date." She looked it over and refused it because it wasn't signed — I had instead printed "SEE MY AWESOME RHODE ISLAND IDENTIFICATION" on the back. "I'll sign it for you right now, let's do it." Not good enough. Surely the combination of all three cards — my signed Rhode Island ID, a bus pass with a recent photo, and an unexpired credit card in my name — should be sufficient? I even let her know that I've been to several airports and never had a problem, to which she said "Well this is DFW!" Oh, my mistake. We continued to argue over how silly it is that a Sam's Club card would be sufficient (her suggestion), but none of what I had.
Chris asked to talk to her supervisor, since we clearly weren't getting any closer to the plane. We all walked over to him, while the woman explained the situation to him in a way that was clearly trying to convince him that I was bad news. He took my boarding pass. "Professor Brian Beck?" he asked, looking it over. "Yes, that's me," I replied sincerely, stepping forward. Since I booked our seats, we were flying as Professor Brian Beck, Reverend Ian Charnas, and Sir Christopher Hesse, naturally. He took my other forms of identification and asked if I had anything else. As a last resort, I selected a family health insurance card from my wallet, positive that it would serve no purpose, having no photo, no expiration date, and several other people with different last names listed.
He held up the insurance card. "What are the last four digits of your social security number?" I quickly recited them. He wrote something on my boarding pass. "Anyone else have any Awesome Rhode Island Identification?" he asked, clearly amused. He returned my boarding pass and we were allowed to continue to the security checkpoint. I was taken aside and patted down while my bags were searched, thanks to a special mark the supervisor had scribbled on my boarding pass. "How paranoid do you have to be..." I thought. I gathered my things after being touched while Chris and Ian waited, then we headed for our gate.
I read my health insurance card closely. There was no trace of a social security number printed anywhere.
Once on the plane, we met up with the remaining members of our criminal mastermind organization. "The old driver's license trick?" they asked, and we all had a laugh. "Fooled them again!!" I thought, arming my wristwatch.
Comments
I love postings like this. Its funny because you have to decide if you are going to be right, righteous, or a jerk.
First, while you are absolutely correct that your ID has no expiration date, it really is your responsibility to make sure that it accurately reflects you. If you lose 100lbs or age 20 years - you shouldn't expect anyone to accept that it is you. While the ID doesn't expire there is a reasonable expectation that you would update it as needed - and one of those as needed situations might be based on you turning 21.
As someone who didn't drive till he was 22 I often got angry at places that said NO state ID. A state ID is a legal form of identification and that is that. If anything that's the only issue in this story I agree with.
The expired RTA bus pass is nul after it expires. It might have your name and your photo and while it might not make any sense after it expires it is considered a non entity. The same goes for a driver's license.
When I lived in Florida I was able to get a Florida Only Driver's license for part time residents. When I would be asked for 2 forms of ID I would sometimes pull out my Ohio and my Florida licenses. People would scoff and be shocked but it was 100% legal and I used it an a legal manner.
But lets look at the other couple of items. Professor, Sir, and Reverend, are titles. If you don't really have those titles then basically you have falsified your name in a similar way of faking an Jr. or a Sr. or a Mr. or a Mrs. While unlike your name which you CAN verify, the moment you start playing games with your name and salutation you are asking for trouble. Asking for trouble is never a good thing.
And the last item is the whole unsigned credit card thing. An unsigned credit card is an invalid credit card. PERIOD. You don't sign it - they shouldn't take it. The signature is your agreement. Remember if they steal your credit card they usually have your wallet and your Driver's License has your signature on it.
When every I am asked for my DL after I hand them my credit card I always say "Remember you should only mug people that you look like!"
In the end - the story isn't as funny as it is tragic that they let you on the plane.
Jared,
I didn't post this to say "how DARE they question my identity and non-professorship!" Rather, the whole idea of heavily guarding such a common form of transportation in this manner is silly. When I get on a plane, I'm not signing a contract or filing my taxes or taking out a loan or representing myself in court. What I think is tragic is the huge waste of everyone's time and money a trip to the airport has become.
Brian,
Thats a very valid point - I can tell you my insane one a few years ago when they were spot checking people as they were boarding the plane. And I was very tired and me and my student were sitting and watching as plane after plane was boarding. Anyways we noticed that whoever got up first got searched. So when they went to board the plane my student whispered to me - don't get up first. So they announce the plane to Cleveland and NOBODY stands up. And she announces it again and nobody wants to be first. Finally one guy said he would do it and she searched the second guy instead.
The question is really what should security look like? I think it should be more like the contract but in some regards you are right.
Yours is a funny story its the credit card thing and the state ID thing that always gets me.
Jared
Papers. May I see your papers please?