New York State gives drivers' license to illegals

Update 9/29/07:
This has to be one of my more lively posts so far this year.

The Republicans in the NY State Assembly have issued Gov. Eliot Spitzer an ultimatum: Rescind an executive order that allows illegal aliens to get driver's licenses or face a lawsuit. Spitzer has until Oct. 31 to withdraw his proposal.

The critics contend the measure violates state law and promotes terrorism. Spitzer argued that the new order will lower insurance rates, train better drivers, and boost security by creating records on illegal aliens.

Meanwhile, New York Secretary of State Lorraine Cortes-Vazquez has announced that she fully supports the Governor's order. Funny for the newspaper to say she is latino. Isn't true that the media always emphasize the minority affiliation for any state and local office holder?

Cortes-Vazquez says it's all about fair play and public safety, who spoke to the Latino Democratic Committee of Orange County.

"By licensing individuals, one, we are also making sure that everybody on the road is insured, so that if you are engaged in an accident, you know that somebody is insured; it's a public safety issue. We will save you $120 million a year as a result of just having more people driving who are insured."

It's not just the GOP by the way. The 9/11 Families are against it. The New York Times did a report on New York's DMV offices that are supervised by county clerks and found that more than 80% of them oppose Spitzer's license plan and will RESIST processing applications that don't include proof of legal residence.

Mayor Bloomberg said, "I'm really skeptical that we should be issuing driver's licenses willy-nilly because it then leads to lots of other problems." To which Spitzer responded, "He is wrong at every level - dead wrong, factually wrong, legally wrong, morally wrong, ethically wrong."

Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver said, "I understand the fear of 9/11 and I agree security is essential, but our nation is an immigrant nation ... and to deny law-abiding immigrant New Yorkers licenses ... is to give into that fear."

Chris Bentley, a spokesman for Citizenship and Immigration Services, said yesterday that the federal government "would prefer that individuals that don't have status don't have legitimate identification documents. But at the same time, the states have the right to produce those."

New York becomes the 9th state to offer licenses to illegal immigrants: Others are Hawaii, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, and Washington.

Folks, if you look at the fine print in Spitzer's executive order, he is allowing illegal immigrants that have a valid and verifiable foreign passport to get a driver's license.

Now how many of the 500,000 to 1 million illegal immigrants living in New York have that? Not a huge percentage, I guess.

Proponents believe that it will reduce insurance costs. Yet, insurers will likely charge illegal immigrants more because of their status and risk of accident. For public safety, I do hope that when they go to take their exam and road test, they will do their best to drive safely and be responsible on the road. However, if an illegal carrying a valid license does get into an accident, then the penalties are much more harsher. Then you have to go into the nitty-gritty stuff if the accident was a fender-bender or an accident that has a fatality.

But this victory could be short-lived. It won't help with border crossings because the Dept. of Homeland Security will require federal passports to be used at the beginning of 2008 to travel by land and air. The REAL ID enhanced license program where states can use their license in subsitute of a passport will not help either. Then New York residents, both legal and illegal, won't be allowed to use their driver's license to travel or enter any government building.

Would any one believe that Gov. Spitzer's actions are illegal? Could a governor choose to take such action without approval by the state legislature?

* * * * *

Governor Eliot Spitzer decided to lift the citizenship requirement for driver's licenses because they cannot ignore the illegals.

"We're changing our policy with respect to getting more people out of shadows and into the system so people don't hide they're here," Spitzer said.

He said the current restrictions on non-citizens have filled the roads with unlicensed drivers five times more likely to get into accidents.

Under the new policy, the Department of Motor Vehicles will accept foreign passports and birth certificates from immigrants as proof of identification. They will no longer need to provide a Social Security card.

* * * * *

Does the Governor really think that giving illegals the right to have a NYS driver's license would really help them? They are still more likely to carry a fake or invalid license. They are still more likely to cause a vehicle accident because they do not know the rules of the road. They are still more likely to flee from the scene of an accident.

Why?

Despite Spitzer's reasoning that it would cut down the number of unlicensed drivers, it would actually give law enforcement agents an easier time to check out the driver's record and determine whether the person has the proper documentation to stay in the state and country.

Actually, this new executive order is pretty much short-lived. If the Federal REAL ID Act is not repealed, it would institute a federal standard on drivers' documents nationwide which will require the use of the SSN.

How about auto insurance? Since they are considered high-risk, any insurance company that wants to do business with them would usually charge higher premiums.

So basically, we are still screwed either way.

Editorials
News Blaze - Against
NY Daily News - For
New York Post - Against

Trackbacks

Trackback URL for this entry is: http://blog.case.edu/james.chang/mt-tb.cgi/15489

Comments

Iam married to an illegal immigrant and we just recentley had a baby girl 5 months ago and due to the fact that Iam a stay at home mother my husband is in despret need of a license for work purposes only. And from past expierenc I know for a fact that Pennsylvania gives auto insurance to anyone with out a social security number... I vote YES !!!!! for giving the license to immigrants. Excpecially ones with families. Jessica Munoz [reacted] please contact me for any furthur information.

gravatar

Posted by: James (Author)
Posted on: September 23, 2007 08:19 AM

It would be nice to get some sort of data to see how many illegals do get auto insurance, but you have to assume it is very low.

It does not help them if they get arrested in any other state, a NYS driver's license won't stop the authorities from deporting the person if he/she was in the country illegally.

gravatar

Posted by: JANET
Posted on: September 23, 2007 10:21 PM

THIS IS FOR YOU JAMES- I AM A HISPANIC AMERICAN CITIZEN, I AM ALSO AN INSURANCE AGENT AND ABOUT 80 PERCENT OF OUR CLIENTS ARE HISPANICS, MOST OF THEM "ILLEGALS" AS YOU CALL THEM, ALL INSURANCE COMPANIES WRITE POLICIES TO "ILLEGALS" REGARDLESS OF CITIZENSHIP. IT IS ALL ABOUT THE MONEY AND POLITICS. THE US NEEDS THE CHEAP LABOR- JUST AN FYI- NO ILLEGAL QUALIFIES FOR ANY TYPE OF GOVERNMENT AID, SO THAT IS NOT THE REASON WHY THEY COME HERE. THEY PROVIDE THE CHEAP LABOR THE US NEEDS, THEY US ALLOWS THEM TO COME AND STAY AND EVERY ONCE IN A WHILE DEPORT A FEW TO PLEASE ALL THE CONSERVATIVE AMERICANS. YOU CAN BUY HOUSES, CARS, CAR AND LIFE INSURANCE WITHOUT A SOCIAL. WITH OR WITHOUT THAT NUMBER YOU ARE STILL "BUSINESS AS USUAL" TO THE BIG FAT AMERICAN CORPORATIONS.

JANET

gravatar

Posted by: James (Author)
Posted on: September 23, 2007 10:42 PM

Why is it that everyone starts off by saying I am a (minority)-American? Also, why think that only the "conservative" Americans are the only ones complaining?

Third, 80 percent of your clients are hispanics, and you admit that they do not proper documentation to stay in the U.S. Perhaps you are fortunate you got folks that want to buy insurance. But what if they get into an accident? It still does not change the result.

You still need a Social for something. Plus when you buy a house, car, insurance, you are subjected to a credit check.

gravatar

Posted by: Pete
Posted on: September 24, 2007 12:56 AM

It is stuped to deni driver licence to any body iligal or legal. I've been in the U.S. since 1988
the first 3 years I drove my car with my Mexican driver licence and my liability insuance issued in New Mexico. after my MEX DL expired I had the opportunity to get a NM DL for 9 years, the first year i did not get insurance, for maybe $80.00 a month, I did get in to a accident, and I had to pay about $5000.00 dlls and $500.00 dlls to reinstate my DL. I learn frome there, that is cheaper to keeper (the insurane), then been paying for accidents. You may not get an accident ever but just in case is better to have DL and insurance.

My wife's driver licence expired 2 years ago, after 5 years of perfect driving record, in tennesse stop issuing driver licence to undocumented PEOPLE so she have to start driving w/o current driver licence to and from the kids school (AMERICAN CITIZENS) she got pulled over and got a ticket for no driver licence, when we went to court, the Judge said to us, I don't know wy the goverments are doing this to you, You probably are undocumented, but no criminal record at all and a clean driving record, now you have to pay $500.00 dlls every time it is sad, butis nothing I can do.

After we pay $6000.00 to $10,000.00 dlls a year in taxes, clean records for all most 20 years a house owners insured drivers, we can not have a driver licence.

I tell you all somthing, not just because 1 or 2 undocumented people become a criminal, all of us are the same way.

gravatar

Posted by: James (Author)
Posted on: September 24, 2007 06:06 AM

It's too bad really. It's a catch-22 pretty much. While there are some folks out there who obey the law and are good drivers, there are some who are not.

What are the percentages? If you get into an auto accident with an undocumented citizen, what are the chances of that person having the proper vehicle registration, insurance, and other paperwork? Probably low.

I wouldn't mind that good, law-abiding undocumented immigrants be given an easier way of attaining citizenship. Those that do not ought to be deported back to their home country.

gravatar

Posted by: Jeffrey Quick
Posted on: September 24, 2007 09:34 AM

Let me start by saying that I don't believe in driver's licenses; we shouldn't need a note from the State in order to travel, especially one that has become a defacto state (soon to be national) ID. That said, I'm not as upset by this as James, even though I'm staunchly anti-illegal. If the purpose is to reduce accidents, this could help, because immigrants will need to know traffic law in order to pass the license test... which of course should be given in English. Liability is a separate issue -- you need insurance to register a car. If an uninsured illegal alien has a liability judgement against him, perhaps he should be sold into indentured servitude until the debt is paid off...and then deported.

gravatar

Posted by: Jeffrey Quick
Posted on: September 24, 2007 09:35 AM

OTOH, that Eliot Spitzer is for this is reason enough to be against it.

Hello everyone. I feel that if someone is to complain about illegals being in the country and come up with reasons why it's bad, I suggest you do your homework first. It's LEGAL to buy a house, car, insurance for home/car, go to college, have bank accounts, and credit cards to build credit. Some banks take certain ID's and TINs (Tax Identification Number) to open up an account. So for the comment about the credit check...Well, it's possible. People get financed for brand new vehicles EVERY DAY without a driver's license and or SSN. So, who's really to blame here? If the United States allows vehicles, houses, insurances, bank accounts and education to illegals lawfully, why is everyone complaining? If it's so bad, call your state representative and complain to them about what the U.S is doing and how the U.S. is only in it for the money and not for its citizens. Not all illegal immigrants are irresposible and uninsured. I can tell you that I know more U.S. citizens with DUI's, felonies, misdemenors and federal offenses than Illegals. What happens when you get off the freeway sometimes? Who do you see asking for money? I see veterans from war and U.S. citizens asking for money when they have a perfectly good SSN and Government issued ID. Why not get a job like the rest of us? Tax free? must be nice! But what I do see is some people who really want to work and feed their families or send money to them selling flowers, fruits and vegtables...Rain or shine. 40 degree weather or 115 degree weather. Why is the finger being pointed at the illegals? If you're going to point the finger...point it in the right direction and I hope it's toward the problem.

gravatar

Posted by: PETE
Posted on: September 25, 2007 12:23 AM

YOU ARE RIGHT CESAR!
I MAKE ABOUT $250,000 DLLS A YEAR
I'M PAYING MY MORGAGE $150,000
I OWN A 2003 F250 POWERSTROKE DIESEL PAID OFF
A 2004 TAHOE PAID OFF
2006 HAYABUSA PAID OFF
3 FOUR WHEELERS
3 SMALL BUSINESS
PAY MY TAXES ON TIME
AND I DONT HAVE A SSN

I DONT SEE WHY MANY AMERICANS CAN'T DO IT.
O I KNOW WHY. IS BETTER TO GET FOOD STAMPS, AND GOVERMMENT HOUSING, THEN MAKE 6 OR 8 DLLS AN HOUR.

NOT GIVING A DRIVER LICENCE TO UNDOCUMENTED PEOPLE, IS NOTHING BUT RACISM, AND NOTHING ABOUT HOME LAND SECURITY.

YOU CARRY A U.S. D.L. AND THEY KNOW WHO YOU ARE AND WHERE YOU LIVE
IF YOU DON'T, YOU KNOW THE CONSEQUENSES.

gravatar

Posted by: James (Author)
Posted on: September 25, 2007 06:56 AM

Note that the NYS DMV will accept valid foreign passports from immigrants, but what if an undocumented immigrant doesn't have one?

Not all undocumented immigrants have liability insurance. In a vehicle accident, the plantiff would have limited options. Over the course of the investigation, depending on the accident and circumstances, if the driver was found to be illegally here, then the state / federal would move to deport that person.

If a U.S. citizen committed an offense, you're looking at a fine and possibly jail time. If you are an illegal, a fine, jail time, then deportation.

Jeffrey, yeah, the national ID schema is big-brother nonsense. The license schema belongs under the purview of the states. I rather think that license tells everyone that you have passed the minimum requirements to drive a vehicle in the state.

gravatar

Posted by: Bill R
Posted on: September 25, 2007 06:35 PM

What is it that some citizens of this country do not understand about the word "ILLEGAL"?????

Not matter how Spitzer or anyone else tries to justify it, to me it is a crime to continue to condone and enable people, ANY people, who are not here legally to continue to stay.

I have nothing against immigrants coming to the USA in a law-abiding manner. What I cannot and will not accept is allowing illegal aliens, "undocumented workers" (or whatever euphemistic label you want to give them), to continue to come into OUR country and expect to reap the rewards of citizenship without becoming a lawful citizen.

gravatar

Posted by: keya
Posted on: September 26, 2007 03:44 PM

the US uses illegal immigrants to the fullest before they discard them,the USA is very unfair and unjust to them.I have been here for 10 years and the system is about exploiting the illegals,by the way I am LEGAL US citizen,wise up give them the driver licences

gravatar

Posted by: Frank
Posted on: September 26, 2007 10:42 PM

Did the first pilgrims come legaly to the US?
HUM!

gravatar

Posted by: James (Author)
Posted on: September 27, 2007 04:08 AM

What is wrong with the basic argument that if you go into any country illegally, you cannot just go there and demand the same rights and privileges accorded to citizens of that country?

As for pilgrims, the 17th century was a different time and place. Maybe we should go back to the beginning of time, and give the land back to the dinosaurs.

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: September 27, 2007 06:40 PM

This is a good thing. Not all illegal immigrant are threats. Why are Hispanic illegal immigrants always looked as if we were terrorists? We didnt maken the attacks, nor did we help them do it. We helped clean it up, and will help to rebuild ground zero. I understand not all illegal immigrants are good, but i think they should come to a happy median, were if a criminal record is found, depending on the the case a license shouldn't be issued. Transportation is a necesity for everybody. There's many US citizens claiming, that because of hispanic immigrants, they dont have a job. Why dont they go and pick apples, tomatoes and oranages? Because they want a job well paid without the proper education, and they see us as escape goeats. They want all the illegal immigrants to leave? Ok so the US ends up without cheap labor, the big company doesnt feel like paying whatever they asking for, so the OUTSOURCE the jobs to other countries. That means no more taxes, college sponsorships, community help, etc from big corporations. If you dont want illegal immigrants, legalize them. They wont be illegals no more. I say vote yes for this proposition, and other states should follow suit. Latinos stand up

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: September 28, 2007 12:18 AM

@ JANET, Illegal immgrants do in fact qualify for government aid. Specifically, Gov. Spitzer is now bending over backwards to have state Medicare cover illegals seeing chemotherapy. And, since it goes agaist federal law, there is no federal reimbursement. In 2006 alone, NYS taxpayers footed the bill for $175,000,000.00 to cover these treatments.


I am really not at all sympathetic to someone who illegally enters and remains in the US. If you want a drivers license, an education, medical care, go and get a visa, a work id#, and then contribute by paying taxes, just like everyone else does. How dare you come into this country with a sense of entitlement, wanting all the benefits of citizenship without bearing any of the financial burdens.


And, yes we are well past the pilgrims. But there were certainly immigrants turned away from Ellis Island, and in droves all throughout the 20th century.


As for the comment awhile back about Vietnam vets begging by the freeway, these people were DRAFTED (against their will) into the U.S. Military to serve in a war about as long and senseless as the Iraq war. If you really want to talk about people being discarded, look at the Vets.

gravatar

Posted by: Luis
Posted on: September 28, 2007 03:03 PM

All I have to say, is that people who are living in this country wihtout legal status, are not doing it, because they want to live like that. They have to be undocumented because of the bad inmigration policies existing in this nation.
If there are millions of inmigrants without SS, it is not their fault. It is the result of inefficient political desicions, made by conservative leaders, who are affraid of loosing power.

gravatar

Posted by: dave
Posted on: September 28, 2007 03:49 PM

"Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"


I guess we might as well take down the old lady. Looks like some no longer embrace her words.

Ironic isn't it?

America used to be the land of opportunity, the great melting pot, willing to accept the 'refuse' and 'homeless' from any land. Come see our purple mountain majesty and walk across our amber waves of grain. If you work hard and contribute to society you can call yourself American.

Now we fight the 'us' vs. 'them' battle. We are Americans. They are not. Lived in the U.S. for 20 years? Still not American. Pay taxes? Still not American. Have you completed the 20 page application in triplicate and passed the multiple choice test? Welcome to America.

We are so far away from where we were. We are so far away from where we should be.

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: September 29, 2007 12:14 AM

Frank, the first Pilgrams did come to the NORTH America legally, because there was no U.S. and the laws did not exist to prevent their entrance or establish a system for them to enter. Now we do have laws and a legal mechanism to be here.

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: September 29, 2007 12:20 AM

"They want all the illegal immigrants to leave? Ok so the US ends up without cheap labor, the big company doesnt feel like paying whatever they asking for, so the OUTSOURCE the jobs to other countries. That means no more taxes, college sponsorships, community help, etc from big corporations. If you dont want illegal immigrants, legalize them. They wont be illegals no more. I say vote yes for this proposition, and other states should follow suit. Latinos stand up"

Why do Americans have to "legalize" the illegal immigrants? Why do they not undergo the process already in place? There is already an existing system and law.

You also suggest if we remove the cheap labor force the jobs will just be outsourced to other countries anyways. And how do you propose that will happen when the jobs that are often done (agricultural and construction) cannot be done from a foreign location. The workers must be on-site in the U.S. to complete their tasks. It cannot be done from elsewhere, not until Star Trek technology becomes reality.

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: September 29, 2007 12:23 AM

And did not the early immigrants that came before the Statue of Liberty follow the laws and policies in place to enter and stay in this country? I do not recall anything related to entering ANY country saying you can enter without obeying the laws of that country. Immigrants are one thing, illegal immigrants are very different.

gravatar

Posted by: Irene H
Posted on: September 29, 2007 05:03 AM

My neice was almost killed by an illegal driver when she was 22 yrs. old. He went out of control and her scull was crushed. She has lived in a semi-coma for many years, costing my family almost everything they had. The man who hit her
had no license, no car insurance, and was let go!! She was not able to receive $1 in compensation!!
I would not want to see this happen to anyone else
over & over! What is the Govenor thinking?! Next thing you know, the illegals will be voting without social security numbers!!

gravatar

Posted by: Tarsha
Posted on: October 1, 2007 12:17 AM

I am strongly Voting YES to the passing of this law because many people are not looking at this situation as a way for people to better themselves their just saying the immigrants are wild and they are going to cause accidents, accidents are cause by people who legal so WHAT THE BIG DIFFERENCE every body deserves a chance and i hope that its taken into consideration and hopefully they pass the law

gravatar

Posted by: bob
Posted on: October 1, 2007 08:36 AM

at Irene

So what would you do with uninsured American drivers?

gravatar

Posted by: James (Author)
Posted on: October 1, 2007 09:38 AM

Bob, well if it was an American driver who is uninsured, then the victim is basically screwed unless he or she has collision insurance or uninsured motorist (UM) coverage.

As for the uninsured driver, that person would face a fine and jail time, as well as legal consequence. In some part, you can still have some sort of legal recourse.

For an illegal, a homicide or drunk driving charge would be grounds for deportation. But I doublt you can get anything from legal or financial recourse from that person.

Tarsha: Gov. Spitzer issued an executive order changing the policy on licenses for illegal immigrants. It can be overriden by the state legislature but there's not enough votes. The GOP opposition is considering legal recourse to get the courts to overturn the policy change.

While we continue to debate whether illegal immigrants should be issued driver's licenses, do you believe that illegal immigrants should be given a chance despite entering this country via illegal means?

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: October 2, 2007 01:30 AM

drugs are illigal, but a grate business for some or all countries.
Illigal immigrants, are a grate business for US, CANADA, FRANCE, SPAIN, GERMANY, AND SO ON.
IF YOU LEGALIZE THEM IT WILL BE NO BUSINESS.
THERE ARE NO VISAS AVAILABLE FOR CONSTRUCTION, DISH WASHERS LANDSCAPE, OR SOME OTHER HARD JOBS,
YOU SAID THAT GO AND GET A LEGAL VIA TO ENTER THE US, AND GET A JOB, OK. BUT THE ONLY LEGAL WORK VISAS ARE FOR HIHGLY EDUCATED IMMIGRANTS, OK, BUT WHO IS GOINT TO CLEAN THIS PEOPLES HOUSES, OR WHO IS GOING TO BUILD THEM HOUSES? THE UNDOCUMENTED HOUSES, BUT TO DO THIS, YOU NEED A CAR, TAGS FOR THE CAR, INSURANCE, AND OF COURSE A DRIVER LICENCE.
65% OF A SMART GREAT AMERICANS, WANT A IMMIGRATION REFORM.
P.S. FOR THE SMALL ANTI ILLIGAL IMMIGRATS GROUP,
(WE DO NOT WANT THE FAMOUSE CITIZEN CHIP) INMEDIATLY. ALL WE WANT IS A PERMIT TO WORK LEGALY IN THE GREAT U.S. YES THE COUNTRY THAT YOU ARE DESTROYING WITH YOUR HATE, AND RACISM.

gravatar

Posted by: James (Author)
Posted on: October 2, 2007 07:10 AM

Yes, more than a majority want immigration reform, but no one wants to give quick citizenship to an estimated 12 million undocumented immigrants in this country. Do you really think it will be that easy to incorporate such a huge number of people in a short amount of time?

Equating illegal immigrants with illegal drugs does not make sense. You are implying that legalizing...say..cocaine and heroin, there will be no business for them...I really doubt that.

Also, there is still a majority of Americans still concerned about illegals coming thru the border. there are some that believe in law and order. there are some that are afraid of basic services being stretched too thin. there are some that are worried about govt services unable to support such an increase.

It's not that easy. Even if you want to reduce the criteria for immigrants to enter this country, you will still have some that will enter the US illegally regardless.

gravatar

Posted by: Guillermo
Posted on: October 2, 2007 01:21 PM

i dont know about you guys. if they dont want illegals then please send them home if you want. you dont want illegals then let your government make the necessary steps to prevent them from getting any support from the government, state or federal. make laws that actually work to eliminate illegals. enough already. if you dont want illegals do your share to eliminate them.
the problem the US needed them!!!
wandering after so many years this people who are against illegals will be taken cared of by illegal caregivers?

gravatar

Posted by: ann
Posted on: October 3, 2007 09:38 AM

Every American citizen needs a social security number to get aloan,bank account even cell phone so why a double standard at tax payer expense. I do believe the system stinks. I believe in temporary workers being temporary. NO drivers license for Illegals this is rewarding people for criminal behavior. Will only increase ins. rates for Americans once again paying the price for illegals. Fix the system no work, no social services, no lisence If a company needs workers sponsor them for the alloted time needed. If a job continues let the employer pay for a legalization process for their workers. These people like some Americans think its the government responsibility to feed cloth and give them health care if not here working no reason for being here. Like children be able to afford them. Do not depend on the American citizen to fund your baby factory. Why do you think Americans have so few children anymore.

gravatar

Posted by: Marth
Posted on: October 3, 2007 12:09 PM

If Funny how those who are against immigrants ask us to go and get legalized, and get a work permit.
Tell you what, I have been here for 10 yrs. since I was 14, went to High School, and now I'm getting a college degree. I still have not been able to get a SSN, just because the US laws wont give it to me. Is not as easy as you see it. you don't just walk into an office and ask them for one.
I came here legaly, had a visa, and a valid passport. But we came looking for a dream, and are now looking to get legalized. We are not bad people, my mom has been able to buy a house and makes like 40k a year, I alsmo make good money without an SSN, but we are also paying taxes, so why couldn't we at least have the benefit of a DL?
at least it would be safer.
I did get into an accident 2 yrs ago, as a Passenger, and getting into an accident wont get you deported, becasue the records go to the insurance company not to the imigration offices.
I agree with Governos Spitzer, it would be easier for everybody, even for american Citizens.

gravatar

Posted by: Vidya
Posted on: October 3, 2007 02:21 PM

I am a guyanese national, living in this country for several years without legal residence. I have been earning a living in this country honestly and have being paying my taxes like any legal resident or US citizen. I am a lic. real estate and a Mortgage processor/Account executive. I bought a house here in the US. I was given a drivers license and couldn't renew it because I don't have a ssn and was unable to get a letter from the ss administration. I was a safe driver during the time I was granted the priviledge to do so. My dream is to go to college and get into the law enforcement system here in the US. Not all illegal aliens as we are labelled, want to live off the government. The last time I checked, it was the lazy Americans, well dressed with all the latest styles and name brands that are standing in the lines with our tax dollars, using food stamps not the ILLEGAL ALIENS. They are the ones that are living on unemployment when they have what it takes to work. We are the ones that are working 12 to 18 hours per day to survive and not sucking the system. For me driving is not a WANT, it is a NECESSITY for my family and I. If God be for us, tell me who can be against us. It doesn't matter what the oppositions are saying. Jesus is in control and no one can prevent us from getting our drivers license once again. God bless Govern Spitzer and I do pray that the others will have compassion over us and stop treating us like we are not humans. We were all created in the likeness and image of God. We are not from another plannet so please stop treating us as if we are. Thanks.

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: October 3, 2007 03:01 PM

F*CK YOU IMMIGRATION I'M STILL HERE

gravatar

Posted by: James (Author)
Posted on: October 3, 2007 06:37 PM

Besides the many number of legalized immigrants, there is also a huge number of undocumented immigrants. Many people are for immigration and desire reform, but many do not want to give a blank approval to the millions of undocumented folks out there. Again, it is not an easy solution.

Spitzer's policy change only affects a certain number of immigrants. Does it mean that the millions of undocumented folk will travel to New York? Who knows?

Besides having a foreign passport (undocumented immigrants won't have that either), you also must have proof of residence too.

Why is it funny if we ask you to go through the process legally? Millions of immigrants have done it before you. Why should you deserve an exception to it?

I am sure we can work out the immigration rules and what not, but the problem is what to do with the 12 million undocumented immigrants living in the U.S. No one has a proper solution to it. You may think it is easy to give automatic citizenship to them, but you fail to see the bigger picture, the consequences and after-affects must be considered.

gravatar

Posted by: JPlotnick
Posted on: October 4, 2007 01:59 AM

Governor Eliot Spitzer is right, and he is a hero!

Those bandit and scoundrel republicans are dividing our society with scare tactics. They are trying to make our country hatemonger's country. We welcome immigrants and their contribution to our society. The Americans who claim not to have jobs and complaining are the lazy scum of our society; we are hard working proud Americans who are not afraid to help the poor and make our society a welcoming society. Governor Eliot Spitzer is a real American whom our forefathers should be proud of. I pray to God he prevails, in which case he already did. For those of you, hateful dirt(s), go join the KKK, live in a trailer somewhere in the South in remote swaps, marry your closest, and do yourself a favor; don’t pollute our welcoming state and our country with your hate speeches. After all is it not a republican who was preying on young boy interns, and the other who took his family value straight to the rest room looking for perverts at least that was told. We are God fearing good and clean Americans, not thieves and perverts. Spitzer is right, let the poor dream as well.

Thank you, may God bless Spitzer and our country; may God give your hateful heart the scent of worship and care. And when I say worship is not worshipping the hateful rep., the overweight and ugly Congressman James Sensenbrenner, whose cholesterol level still out scores his ego and hatred. Why don’t he focus on his health and eating habits rather than scaring Americans with his inflated fear tactics, back room politics and poisons bills; he might as well go and work for groups like the K.K.K. We are a welcoming nation; we feed the poor; we pray to God; we love and respect our family, neighbors and God’s creatures. Why don't we listen to star citizens such as the priests who devoted their lives for the good of men and God; who are telling us to be kind, why do we follow a no good liar republican politician?

It simply beats logic away. Go Spitzer and alike, enough of these lies.

No more voting republican for me.

gravatar

Posted by: Beth
Posted on: October 4, 2007 08:02 PM

Puh-lease! My son had his NYS license revoked and was told he could get it back in November 2006. Seeing he was in Iraq with the US Army last November, as his POA I sent the paperwork. I got back a nasty-gram from the NYS DMV saying his driving record meant he can't get a license until May 2008. My son is a war veteran who spent 7 months of his life defending our country and was in a truck that got hit by an IED and he can't drive in New York. But some slacker who couldn't bother to come to this country legally (or who would have been denied entrance because he's an undesireable) can waltz into the DMV and get himself a license. Please tell me why I thought Spitzer was the man for New York?

gravatar

Posted by: PERLA
Posted on: October 4, 2007 10:44 PM

I AM FOR IT ALL THE WAY!!!

gravatar

Posted by: reusha2000
Posted on: October 6, 2007 04:40 PM

The main reason government exist, its number one, main "JOB" is "PROTECTING ITS LEGAL CITIZENS"!! Local government is the first tier of protection for legal citizens in this country, irregardless of what state and federal governments do. OUR police departments must be allowed to do their JOB. Yes they can ask legal status of anyone in this country, IT'S THEIR JOB! Local police and federal police agencies work together on other cases, this is no difference.

OUR whole country is in harms way giving ILLEGALS a license. They can travel to any state, have an accident, commit a crime and decide Mexico is best to avoid capture. But remember spitzer and NY state made it legal for them to drive while here in the U.S.! SUE THE STATE OF NEW YORK AND THE DEPARTMENT WHO ISSUED THE LICENSE FOR YOUR DAMAGES OR LIVES LOST!! THEY ARE RESPONSIBLE!! If you do a monetary transaction, and burned by the ILLEGAL, because you accepted his state issued license, SUE THE STATE OF NEW YORK AND THE DEPARTMENT WHO ISSUED THE LICENSE!!

"OUR" governments(local,state, and federal) has lost its way, integrity,and credibility. We the People , must take back OUR stewardship. The greedy, ILLEGAL acting, on our behalf politicians must be STOPPED by US, the People!

When Caulderon and V Foxx, boldly and without any regard to "OUR" president, disrespected and tongue lashed, OUR Country and Legal Citizens rights in this country, ON OUR SOIL!! Where was he? Where were OUR representatives?

YOU WORK FOR THE AMERICAN PEOPLE NOT MEXICO!!!!!!!!

gravatar

Posted by: P
Posted on: October 6, 2007 11:37 PM

It is against our US constitution to permit ILLEGAL'S to remain in the country.

If you WANT to live here, get documented. If you're going to go to another country and take residence there, FOLLOW THE LAWS!!! It's THAT simple. And, please, please, please- LEARN THE DAMN LANGUAGE!!
If I go to France, Germany, Portugal, Mexico, China, etc... is everything there in English and that country's language? No, it's not.

This whole illegal immigrant issue is getting out of control.

Anyone who supports illegal immigrants having licenses- GOES AGAINST OUR US CONSTITUTION!

gravatar

Posted by: YAYA
Posted on: October 7, 2007 04:06 PM

LETS GO TO MEXICO WHERE A US CITZENS IS NOT ALLOWED TO BUY PROPERTY AND HAVE IT BE YOURS NO YOU CAN ONLY KEEP IT FOR 50 YEARS AND THEN THE
GOVERMEANT TAKES IT BACK.BUT THEY CAN COME TO OUR
COUNTRY AND OWN HOMES,CARS,BUSINESS,ANYTHING YOU
CAN THINK OF. AND IF WE GO TO LIVE IN MEXICO AND
OUR CAUGHT WE DON,T GET DEPORTED WE GET JAIL.OH
AND THEY DON,T PAY FOR HOUSEING, HEALTH, SCHOOLING
SO MAYBE WE SHOULD HAVE THE SAME RULES IN OUR COUNTRY. GO HOME AND QUIT TELLING US WHAT WE SHOULD DO FOR YOU. YOU WHO HAVE ROAD THIS COUNTRY
TO DEATH GO HOME WE DON,T NEED YOUR DRUGS AND
BASTARD CHILDREN YOU OUR HERE ILLIGALY. WE WILL
CLEAN OUR OWN HOUSES AND BE ABLE TO HELP PAY CHILD
HEALTH OUT OF ALL THE MONEY YOU HAVE COST US.WE
OUR TIRED AND SO WEARY OF YOU AND YOUR GOVERMEANT.
GO AND LET THEM FEED YOU AT THERE TIT FOR A WHILE

gravatar

Posted by: Skeptical
Posted on: October 9, 2007 11:45 AM

I would like to know how the "illegal immigrants" posting on this comment are paying their taxes, the way they say they are.

How do you file taxes without a Social Security number?

Or do you just walk down to the IRS office on April 15 and drop off a bag of money?

ha ha ha ha ha

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: October 9, 2007 02:56 PM

SKEPTICAL.
DON'T BE STUPID, WHEN YOU WORK WITH A FAKE SSN.
THE TAXES ARE DEDUCTED FROM A PAY CHECK, LIKE YOURS IF YOU GET ANY, OR YOU MAY BE LIVING WITH FOOD STAMPS, PLEASE GET INFORMED BEFORE YOU OPEN YOUR HATEFULL, NASTY, AND PERVERT "OSICO" (DOG MOUTH)

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: October 9, 2007 08:28 PM

JPlotnick Talk about HATE and PREJUDICE! You are a SORRY example. YUCK!!

gravatar

Posted by: US Citizen
Posted on: October 10, 2007 02:11 AM

Mexico has armed guards on their southern border. Doesn't anyone know what Sovereignty is? I own a seasonal paint company and legally use imigrants from Mexico. They go home in the winter. Any company can apply for those. My competion cheats and uses Illegal immigrants which really irratates my employees. My workers don't have driving privilages where I live and they don't drive. I pick them up from the apartment complex they live at. I pay their rent and pay quite a bit to the government to cover medical emergencies and other expenses that workers staying here incurr. If we have no borders then I would prefer getting rid of social security, welfare, the right to get medical attention free, food stamps, and public schools. The reason for this is that none of these things were in place when my family moved here from Germany. My wife works at a hospital that loses Millions of dollars every year which makes people who pay for insurance pay higher premiums which leads to companies like mine not being able to offer insurance to my American employees. Local taxes where we live have doubled three times since I moved here to cover the cost of illegal immigrants children getting free school. I am not a racist! But I'd like to know what is going to happen when unemployment goes up to 10% or 20 % like under Carter. Then people will take any job. If their were no illegals my bids would go up to where they were and my employees would be paid more. By the way, the Mexican illegals still cost more than say an immigrant from El Salvador. If they open the borders I'll get twice as much bang for the buck by hiring people from El Salvador. There are no easy answers but handing out driving privilages ins't the answer. If I were here illegally I wouldn't go to the DMV because those records can be suppenoned and you could be deported. You will also need a passport from your counrty of origin. I seriously doubt many illegals have one. Maybe those of you here illegally should take the money you made here back home and help your fellow counry men since 20,000 american dollars equals well over 60,000 back in your county of origin, Mexico. That should be enough to start up your own company at home.

"SKEPTICAL.
DON'T BE STUPID, WHEN YOU WORK WITH A FAKE SSN.
THE TAXES ARE DEDUCTED FROM A PAY CHECK, LIKE YOURS IF YOU GET ANY, OR YOU MAY BE LIVING WITH FOOD STAMPS, PLEASE GET INFORMED BEFORE YOU OPEN YOUR HATEFULL, NASTY, AND PERVERT "OSICO" (DOG MOUTH)"

Hmmmm, you sound like an even tempered sort of chap. No qualms about breaking the law and throwing abuse. Yes, you'll make an ideal US citizen....Not!

OK lets see, I need a passport to go to Canada, but you can hop the fence into the USA and with no documentation get a drivers license? Where is homeland security in all of this? Hey, maybe we should all go and get a second drivers lisence under an "ILLEGAL" name and thats what we'll show the cops when we get pulled over. Come on NY lets all do it. Driving is a privelage not a right!!!

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: October 10, 2007 03:04 PM

the bad thing, is that when somebody open the Hidalgo document, they are going to find out that the rented land (CAL. NM. AZ.TX. WA. NV.)IS STILL MEXICAN LAND, and and a lot of stuped racist porks, are MEXICAN WHITES THAT SUCKS

gravatar

Posted by: bill
Posted on: October 11, 2007 08:52 AM

great idea the best way to help track illegals and make rounding them up at a later time easier.

gravatar

Posted by: matt
Posted on: October 13, 2007 02:01 PM

My parents and me came to this country about 6 years ago we tried to get the papers the visa back where we live and whAT DO WE GET ? the us goverment wont let us we tried about 5 times to get to the us legelly and pay everytime we tried all the us did was take our money and deny us but finally after a long time we decited to go ilegally i am not mexican i am polish and we pay our taxes and we follow all the rules and laws but we still cant get a dl or ssn and i dont live in NY but im hoping they weill do this for all the states

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: October 13, 2007 04:31 PM

God Bless this people, all this conversations, are stuped, instead of been helping each other.
Don't forget, that 700 of the people that dided at the 911 where undocumented people, mostly from Mexico. The terrorist don't discriminate!
that is why We the people who live in the US. legal or illigal, (NOT CRIMINALS) NEED TO BE UNITED WITH THE EYES WIDE OPEN JUST IN CASE.

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: October 15, 2007 07:17 PM

i don't really have a problem with anyone coming to this country.. but if are going to live here learn AND use the language. I shouldn't have to learn another language to accomadate someone else.
how many other countries print road signs,signs in stores,billboards etc.. in another language? run , jump , swim or whatever.. but when you cross the border speak our language.. or at least try even that would be nice..

gravatar

Posted by: DL
Posted on: October 17, 2007 10:23 AM

What part of illegal do you people not understand? What causes them to be here illegally rather than coming here legally?

gravatar

Posted by: Steve
Posted on: October 22, 2007 06:45 PM

What part of ILLEGAL dont you people understand?
If you entered this country illegally you are a criminal already. You do not have the right to ask for citizens rights.... Go home and follow the rules and come back legally or better yet, just find a job there and try to improve your own country.. There is absolutely no reason a country like Mexico, for instance, could'nt be prosperous and productive. Change the laws there, fight the good fight there, develope the social systems there, and LIVE there.

Not racism as Mexican is not a race it is a nationality.... They call this country a melting pot because the legal immigrants come here and blend in with the American culture...They learn the language and live as Americans. They dont come here and try to create the same failed social climate they just left..

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: October 22, 2007 10:55 PM

DL. ITS SIMPLE, THERE ARE NO VISAS, FOR CONSTRUCTION, RESTAURANTES, CLEANING, POULTRY , VEGETABLES PICK UP. AND ALL THIS KIND OF "CHEAP LABOR JOBS". WHY? BECAUSE IT'S BEEN LIKE THAT FOR DECADES, SPECIALY FOR COUNTRIES LIKE MEXICO, AND SOUTH AMERICA, OR COUNTRIES THAT ARE TO CLOSE TO USA.THE PROBLEM IS THAT IF SOMBODY SEE A HISPANIC PERSON, THAT PERSON IS MEXICAN FOR THEM, WHEN THE HISPANIC COMUNITY IS LIKE THE WHITE, FROM DIFERENT ETNITIES.
I KNOW THAT THERE ARE SOME PEOPLE THAT COME TO THIS GREAT COUNTRY, JUST TO DO STUPED THINGS. BUT THERE IS A LOT OF GOOD PEOPLE, THAT EVEN THE AMERICAN PEOPLE FEEL GOOD HAVING THIS PEOPLE LIKE ME AS A NEIGHBOR.
I'VE BEEN LIVING ON A THREE DIFERENT STATES SINCE I COME IN TO USA AND EVERY TIME THAT I HAVE TO MOVE, THE PEOPLE FROM AROUND SAID TO ME THAT THEY WISH SOMEBODY LIKE ME MOVE IN.
MOSTLY WHITE AMERICANS.

NOW, THE VISAS AVAILABLE ARE FOR HIGH QUALIFIED PEOPLE, THAT COME TO THE COUNTRY AFTER A WATING TIME FOR A SPECIAL WORK VISA. BUT WHO IS GOING TO BUILD THIS PEOPLES HOUSES, WHO'S GOING TO CLEAN, COOK, OR SOME OTHER THINGS FOR THIS PEOPLE.
THE ILLIGALS!
LET ME TELL YOU HOW THIS WORKS
THE PEOPLE AGAINST THE UNDOCUMENTED PEOPLE, IS THE ONE THAT DON'T NEED THE SERVICES OF THEM, AND I TELL YOU SOMETHING, IN THE SOUTHERN STATES, LIKE ALABAMA (REAL RACIST) IT'S ONLY WHEN THEY DO NOT KNOW THE PEOPLE. AFTER THEY KNOW US, THEY CHANGE THERE MIND.
YOU CAN SEE THINGS IN 20 YEARS AND 3 DIFFERENT STATES.
MY BEST FRIENDS, ARE THE SAME GUYS THAT USED TO HATE ME.
ABOUT THE BENEFITS THAT WE TAKE FROM YOU ALL, I DON'T REALLY THINK IS TRUE BECAUSE RIGHT HERE IN THE AREA, ARE 3 OR 4 BIG GROCERY STORES WHERE THE UNDOCUMENTED PEOPLE BUY THERE GROCERIES, AND THE OWNER SAID TO ANOTHER PEOPLE THAT HE NEVER SEEN BEFOERE PEOPLE PAYING AROUND $400 TO $500.00 DLLS A WEEK ON FOOD.
THE SMART AMERICANS ARE THE ONES THAT TAKE CARE OF THERE BUSINESS AND LIVE OTHERS TO DO THE SAME.
GOD BLESS AMERICA. AND THE RACISTS TOO.
PS.IT WILL BE GREAT IF I GET A GREEN CARD SOME DAY
TO GO AND SEE MY GRANDMA AND MEET MY IN THE 20'S RELATIVES, THAT I DON'T KNOW.
MY KIDS DON'T KNOW THERE COUSINS, ANTIES. GRANDPAS,OR ANY BODY FROM THE FAMILY.
THE PEOPLE WITH DRIVER LICENCE, IS MORE SECURE, NO METER IF IS UNDOCUMENTED.
JUST REMEMBER WHO HAVE HURT THIS COUNTRY, AND WE ARE'NT

gravatar

Posted by: Doug
Posted on: October 22, 2007 11:38 PM

If your illegal the law has been broken. Why don't we gave people who are waiting to come into this country legally the chance to do all the wonderful things the illegals are doing. I'm sure many of them would gladly take the jobs the illegals do at the same cost perhaps. I know of serveral familys that would the chance.

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: October 25, 2007 11:37 PM

Steve.
yes, like the U.S. it's going to let Mexico's economy to get better, that way everybody is going back to Mexico. I don't think so.

Like China's economy, is going fast, but the US is trying to stop it begining with the toys and everything else.

you need to get more informed.

right now the illigal are good even for the presidential elections, right now everybody is against, after the elections we'll see amnesty or silence.
i tell you what, I bet you, you have not send a dollar to help the californian people. in stead YOU'VE been poisoning good american people with your HATE.
THIS GREAT COUNTRY, IS NOT GREAT, BECAUSE PEOPLE LIKE YOU, IS GREAT BECAUSE THERE IS MORE GOOD PEOPLE AND NOT PUNKS LIKE YOU.
GET LOST!

I live in New Jersey, and i am Ecuadorian national. This is for all those Americans almost or most of them right wing extremists (like those form the talk radio.. w abc...) who hate hispanics or immigrants. We all pay taxes, and No Ilegal Alien who does not have a social security or a green card qualifies for housing, food stamps, unemployment, finantial aid or scholarship...etc.. just beacuse the law does not allow and period. People who use those benefits are american citizens. We immigrants, if we dont work one day that means no food to be brought on the table or les money to pay for rent.
I think most of anti-hispanic-immigrnats hate our skin color or language. Of course, we are the majority of the minority, but also there are ilegal alien who are white(caucasian), but for them it is much easier to merge, ot melt in the masses and there is no questons asked.
If you hate me for this, Someone might forgive you. I have to confess i do not have a green card. Eventhough i work 7 days a week, pay my taxes and all my bills, attend college and pay for it from my pocket because i am not qualified for a finantial aid, and i am an excelent student. Why do you guys ate us that much... money, gold, merchandise, econocmic values travel and move around the world, anywhere, but a human being can not.. and we are considered "criminals". Some of us are Brain Drains from other countries and we come here because some first world countries hit us hard and convert us in poor people with their economic policies!!!!

I agree, if legal or ilegal immigrant, hispanic or non hispanic sells or buys drugs, does not work, comites a crime, steals from others, or is a killer, or sexual predator, or pedophile, terrorist, etc.. put them in the Jail and send them back home.
However, it is not fair, not intelligent to generalize and stereotype everybody as crooks, criminals and low class cheap laborers!!!

When i listen the antiimmigrantes speeches i cna feel their hatress and anger in their soul, but i have also seen other Americans with love, peace and happinness in their heart.

I dont think that allowing the possibility to get a driver licence to some qualified ilegals is a gift nor supporting terrorism.

Thanks


gravatar

Posted by: Igor
Posted on: October 27, 2007 03:30 PM

WOW, so much emotions in this forum !
I can tell peoples' immediate interests involved.
As a rational person, I see few points here:

1) the US is a free market economy, as such it obeys the rule of the market: supply/demand. As long as there is demand for cheap labor, it will keep coming, in different forms: documented or otherwise, if demand is not met.

2) cause & effect, folks: to solve the problem of undocumented labor, you have to create conditions under which it will be unthinkable/impossible for employers to hire undocumented

3) this is all good, and you can pass laws to create a system that will satisfy the above. Main question - what to do with undocumented already here. This is civil rights issue and they WILL be granted their freedoms it's just a matte of when. This is an underclass of people just like the blacks were during civil war and then during Martin Luther King era. Society created the conditions for them to come here and THIS society is responsibly for the issue. It used their blood and sweat when it needed them, after all.

This retarded government, is unable or (and)unwilling to provide the laws. This emptiness gets filled up with so called "illegalness". Correct me if I'm wrong, but you are not criminal/illegal/GUILTY until proven so in a court of LAW, yes law and not fucking Lou Dobbs or Bill O'Reily who demonize poor, hardworking people trying to make it, working for a minimum wage.

gravatar

Posted by: Eric
Posted on: October 31, 2007 12:32 PM

The politicans passed laws To penalize employers who Hire Illegals,but yet they are trying to pass laws so they can drive to work that doesn't make sense. If these people are '' doing the so called Jobs that Americans don't want'' $5-$10 a hour Jobs how can they afford a car iN New York and why do they need one when most people who even work in offices here don't drive to work.whats next these marxist politicans are gonna take extra taxes out of our pay checks so every Illegal or refugee can own a car?

gravatar

Posted by: Eric
Posted on: October 31, 2007 01:07 PM

Politicans put laws in place that peanilize employers who Hire illegals,yet now they want to put laws In place so they can Drive to work that doesn't make sense. If these people are here To do the so called ''Jobs that Americans don't want'' $5-$10 a hour Jobs how can they afford a car In New York? why do they even need one when the majority of people who even work in offices take Public transport?these marxist politicans are Crazzy whats next they will tax us so every Illegal and refugee can own a car!

gravatar

Posted by: malique
Posted on: October 31, 2007 02:45 PM

i just want to say that its a good idea...but how am i goona pay for my insurance if i can't get a job...the whole immigration system is rubish. the polititians are not thinking if they had gave the non immigrants social security number they wouldn't have to work under the table and the country would also make money off their taxes..and trust me there it a lot of non immigrants out there working under the table even with that new law that they have past...how do i know? i am 1 and it does felt great because i dont have to pay any tax, but its not my lost its their's

gravatar

Posted by: politition hater
Posted on: October 31, 2007 02:54 PM

people don't be iliterate.. before you speak, why don't you put your self in a non immigrant situation

gravatar

Posted by: Mark
Posted on: November 2, 2007 12:45 AM

What part of ILLEGAL dont you people understand?
If you entered this country illegally you are a criminal already. You do not have the right to ask for citizens rights.... Go home and follow the rules and come back legally or better yet, just find a job there and try to improve your own country.. There is absolutely no reason a country like Mexico, for instance, could'nt be prosperous and productive. Change the laws there, fight the good fight there, develope the social systems there, and LIVE there.

----------------------------------

They can't make mexico properous, so they come to America and turn it into the toilet they just left. In turn sucking on America's tit, because we allow it. For the idiots (and goddamn there are a lot on here) who keep spouting that illegals can't get assistance, you're sorely mistaken. They're here illegally, so why would they then attempt to do things the correct way?

That's right, with stolen ID's and fake SSN, a lot can be accomplished.

Cesar, you make a quarter of a million dollars, yet you can't spell for shit? So what's your occupation? Drug Dealer? Yeah, I thought so.
So why do you need a fake SSN?


Illegals do NOT need to be here, and anyone who believes so is just a traitor. Simple as that.

gravatar

Posted by: Lacy
Posted on: November 3, 2007 10:39 PM

I've always been taught illegal means wrong and so why are we encouraging illegal immigration. I'm all for someone comming here legally and paying taxes. What I don't like is someone coming here illegally, getting paid under the table, having lots of kids and now they are collecting welfare and food stamps. This is crazy. Don't mooch of our system.... PAY TAXES. I live in San DIego and see many people coming across the border and they cause the majority of the accidents and they have no insurance. I DO NOT WANT TO REWARD them with drivers licenses... what's next, they can vote. Soon they'll have all the rights we have but they still won't have to pay taxes. THIS IS CRAZY that we would even consider it. Why reward bad behavior.

gravatar

Posted by: Mike
Posted on: November 3, 2007 10:46 PM

Gee Pete... it must be nice to be here illegally and have so many nice cars paid for. I guess it's different for the rest of us that need to pay taxes and have really costly health insurance because of illegals that come here and suck our system dry. Mexico is a crap hole and they are turning American into one too! No wonder why all the other countries did away with the anchor baby system- just because you are born here DOES NOT make you a citizen. Try coming here legally like everyone else!

I came to the US from Canada in 1948 after waiting 2 yrs for proper immagration. At that time there was a Quota and Nonquota system. My dad was a self employed business owner and he had funds to support us during our move and residecy. We qualified under a Nonquota system. There were limits on how many people could move to US legally each year. This falls true to other countries also. If there was no Quota then we would have another Mexico City situation in Los Angeles (slowly starting to be that way).The US has to control the influx of foriegn nationals into its society. We cannot have a gang bang (pardon the term). How many people have tried to enter Mexico and look for a job, and not speak the language to boot. They find you working and you are booted out of the country rapido. How do I know this? I was married to a mexican national 20 yrs ago and had a legal visa. Mexicans have to get a visa from the nearest American Embassy if they wish to visit the US. In Mexico City, they issue only so many each day, and not everyone qualifys due to various reasons.I spent 3 yrs there and had the occasion to vist the embassy. People get impatient, especially if they are far away from a embassy like in northern mexico.or far south in Chiapas. One writer says he is here 10 yrs, went to high school and is attending college for a degree. His grammer and spelling is atrocious. I like to occasionlly mispell words intentially to make people think. It sharpens your intellect and makes people aware of others misfortunes. Oh yes people (vast majority) in mexico do not take driving lessons let alone have a license. Why should they bother in the US. I am retired in Baja Mexico 11 yrs and for LACV information Mexicans who drive into Calif have to have a border card,car registration, car insurance for the US and it has to have a vehicle smog inspection. A lot of little do do's. It is no freebe. There are an estimated 25000 americans in Tijuana/Rosarito area. Many comute to work in Calif 5 days a week. In addition there are hundreds of legal mexican workers also going to and from calif jobs. I sometime spend 2 hrs in traffic at the border in the morning hours. just to check my mail at the P.O. box in San Ysidro. Mexico is a nice country and could use a lot of improvement. The people are something else. It takes getting used to. Bottom line is that if you enter a country illegally do not expect to get special favors and treatment to get in front of the line. One final comment " Never bite the hand that feeds you as it may not be there tomorrow " Buenas suarte amigos Stefhen Bagu Rosarito, Mexico

gravatar

Posted by: Pete
Posted on: November 6, 2007 02:21 AM

Mike don't be stupid do you know what is a ITIN
INDIVIDUAL TAX PAYER NUMBER. I guess not,
well is a number that they (IRS) and/or USDT give us insted of the SSN to pay our taxes,
This is for you and all the racist around.
every time that somthing wrong happen to you all or your familys, remember how many times you've discriminated people that come to this coutry to work and not to take your food from your mouth.
Have a marry christmas if you can, because may be a hangry child on this days, and is because a ICE DEPORTED HIS PARENTS BECAUSE YOUR HATE.

Jessica Munoz, you wrote..."my husband is in desperate need of a license for work purposes only."

First, I would ask what country your Husband was from. If he was from Mexico or Canada, he can drive in the United States LEGALLY with the Driver's License issued by those countries. If he is from a country that has a DL that is not accepted on our roads and highways, well, that is just as easy to solve. he can obtain an International Driver's License from his country's embassy. So, what is the problem? He does not need a DL from any of our states. Sorry.

gravatar

Posted by: Eric
Posted on: November 13, 2007 12:16 PM

I don't think the Illegals themselves are such Criminals for just crossing the boarder. I think the law makers and Employers are the ones who are the Criminals.sure people should be screened because maybe 25% who come here are Criminals Most do come for honest reasons though To work make a better life for themselves and families I don't blame them I would probably do the same,But I would rather turn them away then discriminate against my own people Americans for capital gain. It's easy To say Americans don't want this Job or that Job when you have a Ivy league education and never had to be part of the labor force . they want to push these people into the Trucking industry and lower standards and wages that people fought to obtain for over 50 years Just like happened with so many other industries

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: November 14, 2007 06:53 PM

If your here illegally and you damn well know it, and you want to have a better life here in the United States, then by all means, stop your bitching and moaning and do something about it. The very first thing you have to do is contact the Immigration and Naturalization Services and request all the forms needed to adjust your certain scenario. Then go find yourselves and consult with an immigration attorney. The bottom line is that I went through this process for my wife. It takes 3-5 years. A hell of a lot of money. And an awful lot of following ups. But since she had to earn her US Citizenship the "Legal Way", I believe every illegal has to earn theirs too. So stop all your whinings and cryings, and get up off your government assisted asses and do something about your miserable life.

What makes her thing that illegal’s will follow the law by insuring their cars when they are breaking the law to begin with by being here illegally…Issuing drivers licensing to illegal aliens is as irresponsible as Bankers on Wall Street approving home loan to people without social security numbers, and we know what happen there….What planet are these people living in!

gravatar

Posted by: Steven
Posted on: October 15, 2008 11:15 PM

I had my first colorado licence 21 years ago, i got it whilst i was on holiday in colorado, actually i was visiting my mother and stepfather and brother in colorado, by having the colorado licence i was able to drive my familys vehicles and not have to pay the expense of a hire car, 8 years ago i handed in my colorado licence for a florida licence, no problems at all, my family were now living in florida and it was nice for me to be able to use family vehicles.
Things are so different now, after 20 years of having a clean us licence i am now denied this right, apparently the terrorist had a whole bunch of licences from different states and somehow this played some part in the attacks on the world trade centre, also it seems the us anti imigration lobby jumped on the idea that illegal imigrants and terrorist were some kind of bedfellows.
Not many years ago when my family were transfered to florida we used to be able to visit and move around the airbase freely, we could walk from the house out the airbase main gate to the beach and back with nothing more than a hello how are you, things have changed soo much.
I dont think the denial of a licence makes the usa any safer from attacks and nor do i think it discourages poor people from trying to come here, if there really are an estimated 12 millon illegals then how many of them are driving without insurance? i know illegal or not i would rather have someone with a licence and insurance wrecking me than someone without.
I have a property in florida but i am not allowed a licence or id card anymore, to be exact i can have one that lasts 90 days but no more and then it has to be renewed,i have poblems issuing checks because i dont have a state id, my motor insurance costs nearly 400 a month.
Truthfully i am kinda fed up with it all and i have decided to buy property in canada and to invest there as well, i am tired of being treated like a criminal by the us authorities..

Good think Spitzer isn't the Governor anymore, huh?

Here in Denver, I purposely will go out of my way to avoid areas where there are a high number of uninsured drivers. I don't want to take the risk of being in an accident where the driver will flee the scene.

gravatar

Posted by:
Posted on: March 11, 2009 12:41 AM

unless you understand the undocumented, you will never knw the pain they go thru but they have no choice, they are the least to commit felons or crimes, some of them cant even fight for their basic human right. fighting for their children with the citizens because immigration agency will be called upon them, descrimination at work places, living in fear of being deported. driving with no licenses you name all the documents you need to be free. just be a good friend to them and you will be supprised to know how much pain they go thru. come on. am voting yes for the bill

Post a comment





If you have entered an email address in the box, clicking this checkbox will subscribe your email address to this entry so that you are notified if any updates or additional comments occur on the entry.