A Cynical Look at Tom Mendola
As I was preparing to write a blog entry, I remembered that I needed to read the Tom Mendola case. An overwhelming sense of cynicism came over me as I read the page. Individuals can argue over sympathy and welfare all day, but the fact of the matter is that Tom Mendola is a slacker. While quitting school is usually not a great choice, it might have been necessary in his case. However, if he understood the significance of his family's problem, he would have worked harder regardless of his interest in the job. I think the more interesting perspective on this case (especially if we had more information) would be the pattern of poor choices between parents and children. Having ten children you cannot support is about as respectable as being lazy when your family needs you the most. Yes, I know this sounds heartless, but even I cannot have sympathy for Tom Mendola.
Comments
Posted by: Libby Robinson
Posted on: December 4, 2006 05:40 PM
Although I find it hard to speculate on the well-being of Tom Mendola's family, I have little problem commenting on Tom's own performance. In this area I agree with you that Tom's performance warranted release, regardless of personal issues. If not the livelihood of one's own family, what motivation is there?
Posted by: Matthew Gardner
Posted on: December 5, 2006 03:48 PM
I agree that strong evidence exists to justify firing Tom. I'm not even sure businesses need to give much consideration to an employee’s home life. Generally, if an employee needs a job, they'll be motivated to keep it. However, I think you are being a little to speculative. You are right, not enough information is presented. The case mentions reprimanding Tom. We don't know the content of/approach used during those reprimands. There is also the possibility the factory is not set up well and that this problem is more widespread.