Affirmative Action vs. Equal Opportunity Employment

While Affirmative Action (AA) and Equal Opportunity Employment (EOE) have similar goals, they use very different methods, and have very different results.

Both AA and EOE are aimed at equality in the workplace and in colleges, but they achieve this in different ways. EOE merely prevents an employer from discriminating against hiring a possible employee because of race, sex, age, or handicap. AA, however, attempts to establish equality in the workplace by directly controlling the number of minorities and other discrimants in the workplace. For example, a business may hire so that its workforce is 40% caucasion, 30% black, 20% latino, and 10% miscellaneous.

While both aim for the same result, I think EOE is a fair method, while AA is not. An employee should be hired based solely on their abilities and skills pertinant to the job, and race, gender, age, and handicap should not be taken into account (unless the job description specifies otherwise). AA attempts to achieve equality in an unfair way. If two candidates apply for the same job, and one is more qualified, but the other better fits the racial requirement in order to achieve the desired equality, the less capable applicant will get the job, which is unfair.

Trackbacks

Trackback URL for this entry is: http://blog.case.edu/reagle/mt-tb.cgi/2490

Comments

I agree completely. If you are better than the other candidate, you get the job. End of story. Of course, the empoyer still decides who is better, but using race or gender to disqualify somebody is just morally wrong.

People should never recieve a job because they will fill a company's quota for a certain Protected Group. People should be hired on the basis of their abilities to perform the given tasks of the job. I do think diversity is important in the workplace but this particular method of creating it is not right.

Post a comment





If you have entered an email address in the box, clicking this checkbox will subscribe your email address to this entry so that you are notified if any updates or additional comments occur on the entry.